Cultural variety and data in East Asia: ‘foreign brides’ surveys in Taiwan and Southern Korea

Eastern Asian countries are becoming increasingly diverse inside their cultural structure considering that the 1990s. a proportion that is large of immigrants is made of females from China, Vietnam, Indonesia, Thailand and also the Philippines, whom migrated after their wedding to male residents from Southern Korea and Taiwan. To review this brand new set of international residents, the governments of both Taiwan and Southern Korea have actually carried out nationwide studies since 2000. This paper conducts a content analysis associated with concerns among these studies to elaborate a critique associated with the cultural statistics created from them. These studies offer appropriate info on this band of brand new residents, however they likewise have the possible to strengthen current stereotypes that are negative to prior presumptions that shaped the information of questionnaires. The analysis reveals that the manufacturing of data on migrants is affected by three ideologies: assimilation, patriarchy and nationalism.

More information


A version that is previous of paper ended up being presented in the Overseas Conference on Social Statistics and Ethnic Diversity held in Montreal, December 5–8, 2007, arranged by the Quebec Inter-University Center for Social Statistics. We thank Victor Piche, Alan Simmons and two anonymous reviewers with regards to their comments that are constructive. We also thank Belinda Hammoud for research support and Gale Cassidy for modifying. The Social Science and Humanities analysis Council, the Overseas developing analysis Center of Canada, therefore the nationwide Policy analysis Centre at nationwide Sun Yat-sen University of Taiwan supplied funding for research associated with this paper.

1. In this respect, Taiwan varies from South Korea, as it has a population that is aboriginal makes a nation’s population more diverse. Taiwan’s present discourse on multiculturalism will not consist of current migrants from Southeast Asia (Wang Li-Jung 2007 latin mail order wives at Wang , Li-Jung 2007 ‘Diaspora, identification and social citizenship: the Hakkas in multicultural Taiwan’ , Ethnic and Racial Studies , 30 , 5 , 875 95 Taylor & Francis Online, internet of Science ® , Google Scholar ).

2. Those two forms of migration are addressed individually in research, but, the truth is, these are generally connected and associated, as argued by Piper and Roces ( 2003 Piper , N. Roces , M 2003 ‘Introduction: migration and marriage in a day and time of globalization’ in N. Piper M. Roces , Wife orWorker? AsianWomen and Migration , Lanham Rowmand and Littlefield , 1 21 Google Scholar ) and Lan (2008). Immigrant spouses may also be employees (pa >2006 Lee , Hye-Kyung , Chung , Kiseon , Yoo , Myungki Kim , Minjung 2006 ‘Feminization of migration and transnational categories of Korean-Chinese migrants in South Korea’ , Korean Journal of Sociology , 40 . 5 , 258 98 (in Korean) Google Scholar , pp. 290–1).

3. In Taiwan’s recent ‘White paper on Migration’, the federal government has explicitly excluded the likelihood of blue-collar migrant workers settling completely, although it has dedicated a fantastic area of the research to ‘how to attract quality recruiting to stay completely in Taiwan’. See Tsai ( 2007 Tsai , Ming-Chang 2007 ‘Woguo yimin renkou zhengce yanjiu duice that is ji yinying (‘Research on Taiwan’s migration and populace policy and its particular policy recommendation’) , Taipei Ministry of Interior Affairs (unpublished) Google Scholar ). Interestingly, this suggestion is certainly not in keeping with Taiwan’s dependence on inexpensive labour.

4. Those currently naturalized (50,409) are not counted (Korea Immigration Policy Committee 2009 Korea Immigration Policy Committee 2009 ‘The 1st master arrange for immigration policies (2008–2012)’ (in Korean) Google Scholar ).

5. This number would not consist of 17,563 commercial students.

6. When it comes to Taiwan, the issue of ‘population quality’ is raised in a variety of means. Federal federal federal Government officials make statements from the significance of keeping this quality when it comes to future competition associated with the nation. For examples, see Wang and Belanger (2008).

7. Until December 2002, migrant employees had been prohibited for legal reasons from employed in the solution industry. Since 2002, the Korean federal government has permitted cultural Koreans to acquire work in a few service sectors, including work that is domestic. This ‘Employment Management Program’ had been further became and improved the ‘Visit and Employment Program’ in March 2007.

8. In 2008 this role was taken over by the Ministry of Health, Welfare and Family Affairs february.

9. It’s also the full instance when it comes to method they truly are portrayed in Vietnamese news (see Belanger, Khuat and Wang 2007).

10. a detail by detail conversation for this debate between some feminist teams and scholars could be accessed at ‘Wuneng queyao jinhun de guodu’ (‘An impotent state forbids cross-border marriage’),

11. From the Taiwanese questionnaire, a red-inked mark appears that defines ‘developmentally retarded children’ as ‘children under the chronilogical age of six whom suffer with deviant development and need early treatment’.